Title

Is Gay the New Black? An Intersectional Perspective on Social Movement Rhetoric in California’s Proposition 8 Debate

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

2015

Publication Source

Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies

Volume

12

Issue

1

Inclusive pages

63-82

DOI

10.1080/14791420.2014.995684

Abstract

This essay charts a critical intersectional rhetoric as a means for understanding the articulation of a Civil Rights Movement (CRM) analogy in marriage equality campaigns. Analyzing the campaign against Proposition 8, California's version of the Defense of Marriage Act, I argue that the use of such analogizing elides difference, prevents meaningful and complex conversations about power and oppression, and makes visible the material intersectional tensions between and among communities of color and gay and lesbian communities and how these discourses further marginalize those that identify as queer people of color. Through criticism of campaign commercials, movement strategy, and the protest rhetoric after the proposition passed, I argue that CRM analogy discourse historicizes racism, privileges white gay identities, and exacerbates divisions that prevent coalition building.

Keywords

Critical Rhetoric, Intersectionality, Gay Marriage, Civil Rights Rhetoric, Proposition 8

Disciplines

Communication

This document is currently not available here.

  Contact Author

Share

COinS